Volunteers cannot improve when leaders give only vague criticism
- confirmed
- 0
- pain / 5
- β
- this week
- 0%
A student regularly helps lead a marching-band support group, but was told they should not become an official leader because people had called them bossy.
community validations
validation growth, last 7 days
community average, out of 5
how often it happens
approved by moderators
0 anonymous followers Β· 0 shared workarounds
A student regularly helps lead a marching-band support group, but was told they should not become an official leader because people had called them bossy. They were not given concrete examples and feel their extra work goes unrecognized.
Students volunteering in school groups and seeking leadership roles
How often it happens
How painful it is
5.0 / 5
Average pain reported by the community (1 = minor annoyance, 5 = extremely painful).
Aggregated from 1 anonymous validations. Individual answers are never shown.
How people deal with it today.
No workarounds shared yet. How do you deal with it today?
Ways people are currently trying to solve this problem. Upvotes are separate from problem validations.
No solutions listed yet. Do you know a product, service or approach that helps with this problem? Share it below.
2 comments
Anonymous Β· 17 Oct 2026
Itβs hard to improve when all you get is βyou need to be a better leader.β Try asking about one specific situation instead: βIn that meeting, whatβs one thing I could have done differently?β That gives people something concrete to answer. People may also worry about how youβll react, especially if youβre leading them. If someone does give you criticism, thank them and ask a question to understand it before explaining your side. Then follow up later with what you changed. If nobody involved will talk, you could walk a mentor through a specific incident, including what you said and did, and ask where you might have handled it better. They wonβt have the full picture, but they may help you spot something you missed.
Anonymous Β· 17 Oct 2026
From the OneMillionProblems team: Another angle is to agree on your role before the next group task: what are you responsible for, and which decisions belong to the official leaders? Being the person who quietly takes on extra work can leave everyone with different expectations. Ask the adviser for one small task to coordinate, with a quick review afterward. That gives you a chance to practice leading and get feedback on something everyone actually observed.